3DEM History and Genealogy 1968-2011
Welcome to the Web Page on the History of 3-Dimensional Electron Microscopy in Biology
Since the inception of the field of 3-Dimensional Electron Microscopy in Biology in 1968 there has been remarkable growth in the number of labs and scientists active in the field of 3DEM.
The aim of this website is to provide links to some of the original papers which spawned the field and reviews which have chronicled the subsequent development of the field. Several of these resources are published personal accountings by colleagues who were central in the field, and also narratives written especially for this project.
An attempt has been made to present a genealogy reflecting the original groups in the field and to show how the field has propagated from the few pioneer laboratories in 3DEM, and the interrelationships between them.
The genealogy data in the map has purposely been cut off at the year 2011. This arose because of the almost exponential rise in 3DEM activity since this date. We felt that chronicling the early steps of the development of the field would provide a valuable resource in understanding how the field evolved.
Here is a link to the criteria used for inclusion in the genealogy.
We rely on you, our colleagues, to make further contributions to the website and to guide us in the accuracy of the facts we present. Please feel free to contact us (Alexis, Martin, Ardan)!
Network Visualization
This is an attempt at an academic genealogy of the field of 3D EM and is a work in progress.
Academic genealogy: Frequently Asked Questions
This genealogy aims to record the growth of the field of 3D EM from 1968 to 2011
Who is included?
Researchers who hold or have held permanent positions and who have made a significant contribution to the field of 3D EM. PhD students, postdocs and other non-permanent scientists are not included. Tenure-track faculty are included.
Technical Staff with more than 5 publications in the field of 3DEM are also included in the list.
What do arrows signify?
Links denote mentorship. Typically, PhD supervisor – student and PI – postdoc relationships are denoted by links. If a person trained or worked in more than one lab, these relationships may be indicated.
Why are some nodes larger, more visible than others?
The choice of which nodes to emphasize aims to reflect:
- Those scientists who initiated the field of 3D EM
- The number of their academic “descendants”
- The fact that some researchers entered the field independently of others, in a sense becoming “first-generation” contributors
Why is X not included? I can see errors, can they be corrected?
Since there is no authoritative source for information needed to compile this genealogy we rely on feedback to ensure there are no omissions or other mistakes.
Development of the field of 3DEM
Publications related to the history of 3D EM
| David DeRosier | 3D reconstruction from electron micrographs a personal account of its development | Methods Enzymol. 2010;481:1-24 |
| Bob Glaeser | Review: Electron Crystallography: Present Excitement, a Nod to the Past, Anticipating the Future | J Struct Biol. 1999 Dec 1;128(1):3-14 |
| Ken Taylor, Bob Glaeser | Retrospective on the early development of cryoelectron microscopy of macromolecules and a prospective on opportunities for the future | J Struct Biol. 2008 Sep;163(3):214-23 |
| Obituary: Walter Hoppe | J. Appl. Cryst. (1987) 20, 324-325 | |
| Bruno Strasser, Jacques Dubochet | Obituary: Eduard Kellenberger (1920-2004) | Nature. 2005 Feb 24;433(7028):817 |
| Marin van Heel | Jean-Pierre Bretaudière (1946-2008) and the early days of multivariate statistics in electron microscopy | In: "An electronic text book: Electron microscopy in Life Science", 3D-EM Network of Excellence, Editors: A. Verkley and E. Orlova (2009) |
| R. Nuzzo | Profile of Chikashi Toyoshima | Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2006 Jan 31;103(5):1165-7 |
| Aaron Klug | Aaron Klug - Autobiography | Nobelprize.org. 17 Jul 2011 |
| Don Caspar, David DeRosier | The 1982 Nobel Prize in chemistry | Science. 1982 Nov 12;218(4573):653-5 |
| John Finch | A Nobel Fellow on Every Floor | Book published by MRC/LMB |
| Anthony Crowther | From Envelopes to Atoms: The Remarkable Progress of Biological Electron Microscopy | Adv Protein Chem Struct Biol. 2010;81:1-32. |
| Viruses and the development of quantitative biological electron microscopy | Notes Rec R Soc Lond. 2004 Jan;58(1):65-81. | |
| Nikolai Andreevich Kiselev | Nikolai Andreevich Kiselev (On the Occasion of His 80th Birthday) | Kristallografiya, 2008, Vol. 53, No. 6, pp. 1149–1150. translated in Crystallography Reports, 2008, Vol. 53, No. 6, pp. 1091–1092 |
| Wolfgang Baumeister | A voyage to the inner space of cells | Protein Sci. 2005 January; 14(1): 257–269. |
| Arthur L Robinson | Electron Microscopy: Imaging Molecules in Three Dimensions | Science 1976 April; Vol. 192 no. 4237 pp. 360-400 |
| Jacques Dubochet | Cryo-EM—the first thirty years | Journal of Microscopy 2011; Vol. 245 no. 3 pp. 1-4 |
| Aaron Klug | A Long Way from DurbanA Biography | Cambridge University Press, 2017 |
| Joachim Frank | Single-particle Cryo-electron Microscopy: The Path Toward Atomic Resolution/Selected Papers Of Joachim Frank With Commentaries (Series in Structural Biology) | April 6, 2018 |
Original personal narratives
These narratives were specially provided to this 3DEM history website by the authors below. We welcome further contributions.
| Robert Josephs | A profile of a researcher in the field of electron crystallography | October 2015 |
| Michael Rossmann | A short scientific autobiography of Michael G. Rossmann | September 2011 |
| Ondreij Krivanek | Ondrej Krivanek’s contribution to microscopy: Memories of an adventure! | August 2018 |
Other Links
Web of stories: video interview of Aaron Klug & Nobel interview with Aaron KlugContributors
Hebrew University of Jerusalem and the National Cancer Institute, NIH
Quick links
Recent Entries
(Show all)Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
Cryo EM structure of a formate acetyltransferase (PFL) from Amygdalobacter nucleatus
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
Cryo EM structure of GTP cyclohydrolase 1 (FolE) from Mycobacterium tuberculosis in complex with 8-oxo GTP
Arabidopsis thaliana V-type ATPase, State 1 bound to OXR5, Backbone model
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
Cryo EM structure of a formate acetyltransferase (PFL) from Fannyhessea vaginae
Porcine ATP synthase with inhibitory protein IF1, F1 domain, E-state
Cryo-EM of chaperon usher pathway pilus from Stenotrophomonas maltophilia
Cryo-EM structure of the T641E mutant of the outwardly rectifying potassium channel TOK1 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae
Cryo-EM structure of the outwardly rectifying potassium channel TOK1 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae in a GDN micelle
Cryo-EM structure of homo-hexameric hLRRC8A double mutation W168L/L402W
Cryo-EM structure of homo-hexameric hLRRC8A double mutation I2C/L402W
Human GGPPS Bound to Selective Inhibitor CML-07-119 in theExposed Binding Site Conformation
Human GGPPS Bound to Selective Inhibitor CML-07-119 in theShielded Binding Site Conformation
Cryo-EM Structure of Human GGPPS Bound to Selective Inhibitor CML-07-119
Prefusion-stabilized Nipah virus fusion protein in complex with inhibitory nanobody F112
Prefusion-stabilized Hendra virus fusion protein in complex with inhibitory nanobody F123
Cryo-EM structure of the NLRP3 decamer bound to the inhibitor BAL-1516
Cryo-EM structure of ESG-2-36-bound D3 dopamine receptor with mini-Go
Cryo-EM structure of Free fatty acid receptor 2 (FFA2)-ARK1 with GLPG0974
Cryo-EM structure of Arthrobacter psychrolactophilus Trehalose synthase
Cryo-EM structure of SARS-CoV-2 receptor binding domain in complex with CS-42 Fab (local refinement of RBD and Fv)
Cryo-EM structure of SARS-CoV-2 receptor binding domain in complex with SR-23 Fab (local refinement of RBD and Fv)
Cryo-electron tomography of AF647-gold-conjugated W27 binding to E.Coli membrane blebs.
5HT2AR-miniGq heterotrimer in complex with a selective agonist IHCH-2330
5HT2BR-fab heterotrimer in complex with a novel antagonist IHCH-2330
Structure of AlphaIIbBeta3-R21C11 Fab in the near-bent conformation
KN1dep depolymerase with C1 symmetry against KN1 serotype Klebsiella pneumoniae,(KN1dep-C1)
Tetrameric cystathionine beta-synthase of Mycobacterium tuberculosis bound to O-Benzylhydroxylamine
Tetrameric cystathionine beta-synthase of Mycobacterium tuberculosis bound to AOAA
Cryo-EM structure of Dp42 depolymerase with C1 symmetry against KN1 serotype Klebsiella pneumoniae,(Dp42-C1)
Cryo-EM structure of Dp42 depolymerase with C3 symmetry against KN1 serotype Klebsiella pneumoniae,(Dp42-C3)
structure of human propionyl-coenzyme A carboxylase in BC binding state
Cryo-EM structure of the Arabidopsis thaliana C4S4M4-type PSII supercomplex focused map part B
Overall structure of STOM-liposome reconstructed with C16 symmetry.
Cryo-EM structure of the Arabidopsis thaliana C4S4M4-type PSII supercomplex focused map part C
C-terminal focused EM map of STOM-double reconstructed with C8 symmetry
Cryo-EM structure of the Arabidopsis thaliana C4S4M4-type PSII supercomplex focused map part D
Cryo-EM structure of DONepi, a deoxynivalenol 3-epimerase from Nocardioides sp. S5-5
Cryo-EM structure of the Arabidopsis thaliana C2S2M2-type PSII supercomplex focused map part C
Cryo-EM structure of the Arabidopsis thaliana C2S2M2-type PSII supercomplex focused map part A
Cryo-EM structure of the Arabidopsis thaliana C2S2M2-type PSII supercomplex focused map part B
C-terminal focused EM map of STOM-single reconstructed with C8 symmetry
Cryo-EM structure of the Arabidopsis thaliana C4S4M4-type PSII supercomplex focused map part A
C-terminal focused EM map of STOM-liposome reconstructed with C8 symmetry
CryoEM structure of EV-D68 US/MO/14-18947 in complex with MFSD6-L3
CryoEM structure of EV-D68 US/KY/14-18953 in complex with MFSD6-L3
Local refinement cryo-EM map of CXXC-NCP component of the mutant MHKKKQ DNMT1-umNCP complex
Composite cryo-EM density map of DNMT1 in complex with unmethylated nucleosome core particle
Alternative NBD1-binding geometry in channel-formed, ATP-bound, VX809-bound, T2a-nanobody-bound wild-type human CFTR (Composite map from PHENIX)
V-shaped (channel-formed), ATP-bound, VX809-bound conformation of wild-type human CFTR (sharpened AHD1 local refinement map from cryoSPARC)
Local refinement cryo-EM map of DNMT1 C-terminal domains in complex with unmethylated nucleosome core particle
Local refinement cryo-EM map of DNMT1 CXXC domain in complex with unmethylated nucleosome core particle
Cryo-EM consensus map of the DNMT1 in complex with unmethylated nucleosome core particle
Local refinement cryo-EM map of mutant MHKKKQ DNMT1 component of the mutant MHKKKQ DNMT1-umNCP complex
Cryo-EM consensus map of the mutant MHKKKQ DNMT1-umNCP complex showing the density of the RFTS domain
Cryo EM Structure of Full Length mGluR8 Bound to Agonist L-AP4 and PAM VU6005649
Cryo EM Structure of Full Length mGluR8 Bound to Agonist L-AP4 and PAM VU6005649, class 2
Cryo-EM structure of a novel beta-galactosidase (EiGH116) from animal gut
Cryo-EM structure of a novel beta-galactosidase (HhGH116) from human gut
Complex of FMDV O/18074 and porcine-derived neutralizing monoclonal antibody pO18-29
Complex of FMDV O/HN/CHA/93 and porcine-derived neutralizing monoclonal antibody pO18-29
Human sperm 20S-AAA-ATPase proteasome complex isolated from native source
Human sperm 20S-PA200 proteasome complex isolated from native source
cryo-EM structure of wild-type MscL from Escherichia coli in MSP nanodisc
cryo-EM structure of MscL G22S mutant from Escherichia coli in MSP nanodisc
Focused subtomogram average of the transition zone linker (linker1) in human airway cilia
In situ subtomogram average of the transition zone linker in human airway cilia (composite map)
Focused subtomogram average of the transition zone linker (linker4) in human airway cilia
Focused subtomogram average of the transition zone doublet microtubule (d) in human airway cilia
Focused subtomogram average of the transition zone doublet microtubule (c) in human airway cilia
Focused subtomogram average of the transition zone doublet microtubule (b) in human airway cilia
Cryo-EM Structure of GTP Cyclohydrolase I from Candida albicans bound to 7-Deaza GTP and BH2 at 1.96 A
Focused subtomogram average of the transition zone linker (linker3) in human airway cilia
In situ subtomogram average of the transition zone linker in human airway cilia (consensus map)
Focused subtomogram average of the transition zone doublet microtubule (a) in human airway cilia
Focused subtomogram average of the transition zone doublet microtubule (e) in human airway cilia
Focused subtomogram average of the transition zone linker (linker2) in human airway cilia
RNA polymerase ribozyme 85h34 replication complex, consensus structure.
In situ subtomogram average of the transition zone doublet microtubule in human airway cilia (consensus map)
RNA polymerase ribozyme 85h34 replication complex, subclass 2 structure.
In situ subtomogram average of the transition zone doublet microtubule in human airway cilia (composite map)
V-shaped (channel-formed), ATP-bound, VX809-bound conformation of wild-type human CFTR (sharpened WalkerB2 local refinement map from cryoSPARC)
Cryo-EM structure of a bovine CLC-K S68N/R355K chloride channel with inhibitor M-BIM1
V-shaped (channel-formed), ATP-bound, VX809-bound conformation of wild-type human CFTR (sharpened AHD2 local refinement map from cryoSPARC)
Cryo-EM structure of a bovine CLC-K S68N/R355K chloride channel with inhibitor M-BIM15
V-shaped (channel-formed), ATP-bound, VX809-bound conformation of wild-type human CFTR (sharpened WalkerB1 local refinement map from cryoSPARC)
V-shaped (channel-formed), ATP-bound, VX809-bound conformation of wild-type human CFTR ( Consensus map from cryoSPARC)
V-shaped (channel-formed), ATP-bound, VX809-bound conformation of wild-type human CFTR (sharpened CORE1 local refinement map from cryoSPARC)
Cryo-EM structure of a bovine CLC-K S68N/R355K chloride channel with 100 mM Ca2+
V-shaped (channel-formed), ATP-bound, VX809-bound conformation of wild-type human CFTR (sharpened CORE2 local refinement map from cryoSPARC)
Local refinement of XRCC3-RAD51-RAD51 body of DX2-CX3 bound to RAD51 filament
Local refinement of RAD51 filament body of DX2-CX3 bound to RAD51 filament
Cryo-EM structure of apo full-length mouse TRPML2 channel in lipid nanodisc, closed II
Local refinement of CDX2 body of DX2-CX3-RAD51 filament, unsharpened map
Cryo-EM structure of apo full-length mouse TRPML2 channel in lipid nanodisc, closed III
Cryo-EM structure of the 2:2 mGlu7-ELFN1 complex in conformation D
Cytochrome bc1 complex from Rhodobacter capsulatus at 2.16 A resolution
R. capsulatus cytochrome bc1 dimer with one Rieske protein in the c position and one in an intermediate position
Cryo-EM structure of ESG-2-37-bound D3 dopamine receptor with mini-Go
R. capsulatus cytochrome bc1 dimer with both Rieske proteins in the b position
R. capsulatus cytochrome bc1 dimer with both Rieske proteins in the c position
R. capsulatus cytochrome bc1 dimer with one Rieske protein in the c position and one in the b position
Rhodobacter capsulatus +2Ala insertion mutant of cytochrome bc1 dimer at 2.41 A
Cryo-EM structure of EA-Ri-112-bound D3 dopamine receptor with mini-Go
Focused map of mGlu7 TMDs-beta-arrestin 1 in mGlu7-beta-arrestin 1 complex
Cryo-EM structure of the 2:2 mGlu7-ELFN1 complex in conformation C
Cryo-EM structure of the 2:2 mGlu7-ELFN1 complex in conformation B
Cryo-EM structure of the 2:2 mGlu7-ELFN1 complex in conformation A
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
The spike protein of HCoV-OC43 obtained from data collected on 300 kV Krios with Gatan K3 detector
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
CryoEM Structure of human MDA5 with dsRNA (one protein subunit on dsRNA)
Cryo EM structure of a peroxidoxin from Trypanosoma brucei (reduced form)
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
The spike protein of HCoV-OC43 obtained from data collected on 100 kV Tundra with Ceta detector
Structural insights into the exosite-mediated activation of Factor IX by Factor XIa using cryoEM
CryoEM Structure of human MDA5 in complex with dsRNA (two protein subunits on dsRNA)
