3DEM Structure-Map Validation
August 20, 2025
A new publication describes two percentile-based metrics: Q_relative_all and Q_relative_resolution. The publication presents a statistical analysis of Q-score and these new percentile based validation metrics (expanded on below).
Q_relative_all is a single value percentile, representing the overall quality of the model-map fitness. It is derived by comparing a model-map average Q-score to all model-map average Q-scores calculated for 3DEM structures in the PDB/EMDB. Higher Q_relative_all percentile values, infer higher quality in the model-map fitness.
Q_relative_resolution is a single value percentile, derived by comparing the average Q-score of a model-map with the Q-scores of other model-map entries of similar resolution. This metric was developed from the principle that average Q-score is correlated with map resolution. Q_relative_resolution percentile values close to 50% therefore represent a score that is commonly observed for entries in the PDB/EMDB of similar resolution, inferring model-map fitness is typical for an entry of a particular resolution. Notably low or high Q_relative_resolution percentiles may be helpful to guide further review of model-maps.
The EMDB has made these metrics available since Spring 2024 via emdatabank.org and since the publication of the paper, the wwPDB is in the process of incorporating these metrics into wwPDB validation reports by providing the Q-score percentile slider for the assessment of model-map fitness of 3DEM entries. This validation enhancement will help depositors, reviewers and the community to improve the quality of data submissions and assist users to assess 3DEM data quality in the PDB and EMDB, wwPDB core archives.
Q-score as a reliability measure for protein, nucleic acid and small-molecule atomic coordinate models derived from 3DEM maps
Grigore Pintilie, Chenghua Shao, Zhe Wang, Brian P Hudson, Justin W Flatt, Michael F Schmid, Kyle L Morris, Stephen K Burley, Wah Chiu. (2025) Acta Cryst D81: 410-422 doi: 10.1107/S2059798325005923
Quick links
Recent Entries
(Show all)
Cryo-EM Structure of YfdQ Reveals a Widespread Novel Family of Bacteriophage-Associated Proteins with Shell-Like Assemblies
Structure of the human astrovirus VA1 capsid spike bound to antibody 7C8
Structure of the human astrovirus VA1 capsid spike bound to antibody 2A2
Structure of the Bombyx mori bmCENP-HIKM-LN-T-OP complex without the CS module
The dimeric KICSTOR-GATOR1 supercomplex (constitutive GATOR1 dimer, SZT2 fragment)
Eukaryotic translation initiation factor 2-B (eIF2B) bound to phosphorylated eIF2alpha (NTD)
BG505 MD39.3 Env gp151 MPER nanodisc in complex with DH511.2, BG18, and VRC01 Fabs
Nipah virus fusion protein ectodomain in complex with 8C7 antibody fab
Hendra virus fusion protein ectodomain in complex with 9A9 antibody fab
Structure of human TRPV3-Q580P Olmsted syndrome mutant in the closed state
Light chain amyloidosis double protofilament amyloid fibril - IGLV6-57
Refined plasminogen binding group A streptococcus M-like protein isolate from AP53 bound to human plasminogen
CryoEM structure of WNV (Kunjin strain) with the Fab of WNV-86 antibody
Cryo-EM structure of HAdV-C6 hexon trimer in complex with human coagulation factor X (FX)
Cryo-EM structure of HAdV-C5 hexon trimer in complex with human coagulation factor X (FX)
Cryo-EM structure of HAdV-C6 hexon trimer in complex with prothrombin (FII)
RQd20_wk56_28 Fab in complex with V703-0537_L14 SOSIP and 3BNC117 Fab
Hedgehog coronavirus ErinCoV-12-19 spike receptor binding domain in complex with hedgehog APN (locally refined)
Hedgehog coronavirus ErinCoV-Ger12 spike receptor binding domain in complex with hedgehog APN (locally refined)
Hedgehog coronavirus ErinCoV-Ger12 spike receptor binding domain in complex with hedgehog APN
Hedgehog coronavirus ErinCoV-12-19 spike receptor binding domain in complex with hedgehog APN
CryoEM map of Yeast RNA polymerase II elongation complex apo-state-I-A
CryoEM map of Yeast RNA polymerase II elongation complex apo-state-I-B
Structure of Yeast RNA polymerase II elongation complex apo-state-I
Structure of Yeast RNA polymerase II elongation complex with NTP-state-VII-A
Structure of Yeast RNA polymerase II elongation complex with NTP-state-VII-C
Characterization standard for in-situ cryo-electron tomography: structure of PP7 virus-like-particle in E. coli from plunge freezing by single particle analysis
Subtomogram averaged porcine UOX assembly map with helical symmetry applied
Subtomogram averaged mouse UOX assembly map with helical symmetry applied
Subtomogram averaged rat UOX assembly map with helical symmetry applied
15-subunit assembly of cyanide dihydratase from Stutzerimonas stutzeri (Pseudomonas stutzeri AK1)
Dark-state structure of human medium-wavelength cone opsin (OPN1MW)
Assembly intermediate of human mitochondrial ribosome small subunit in complex with NOA1, ERAL1, METTL17, MCAT and TFB1M (state N1)
Structure of the O-oligosaccharyl transferase PglL from Neisseria meningitidis in complex with a nanobody
Cryo-ET structure of N-terminally truncated membrane-bound EHD2 complex
Cryo-EM structure of the SbmA V102G mutant variant in an expanded outward-open conformation
Structure of the SARS-CoV spike glycoprotein in complex with a homotrimeric Bicycle molecule - state with one RBD-up
Cryo-EM structure of the human potassium chloride cotransporter T906A/T1007A phospho-knockout mutants KCC2b bound ATP in LMNG (outward-facing state, dimer)
CryoEM structure of WIV1 spike monomer in complex with neutralizing antibody V1WT_41
CryoEM structure of WIV1 spike monomer in complex with neutralizing antibody V1WT_06
CryoEM structure of WIV1 spike monomer in complex with neutralizing antibody VA14_26
GT-C O-Mannosyltransferase TMEM260 co-purified with natural donor and in complex with acceptor peptide
Structure of a stalled E. coli 70S RNC-NuoK-70 in complex with SecYEG-YidC (Focused Refinement)
Structure of a stalled E. coli 70S RNC-NuoK-70 in complex with SecYEG-YidC (Consensus Refinement)
Structure of a stalled E. coli 70S RNC-NuoK-86 in complex with SecYEG (Consensus Refinement)
Extended tail of C. difficile phage phiCD508 subjected to 3D variability analysis
C. difficile phage phiCD508 tail tube in spontaneously contracted state
C. difficile phage phiCD508 tail sheath in spontaneously contracted state
Amyloid beta oligomer Interactions with Extracellular Vesicles by Cryo-ET
AMG986-bound APLNR dimer in active state 2b in complex with Gi-protein
AMG986-bound APLNR dimer in active state 2a in complex with Gi-protein
Cryo-EM structure of drosophila TRPgamma determined in GDN, state 1
Cryo-EM structure of drosophila TRPgamma determined in GDN, state 2
Cryo-EM structure of two abaucin-bound LolDF in Acinetobacter baumannii
Cryo-EM structure of nucleotide-free LolDF in Acinetobacter baumannii
Cryo-EM structure of four abaucin-bound LolDF in Acinetobacter baumannii
Cryo-EM structure of Medicago truncatula GA3-GID1b-DELLA1 ternary complex
Cryo-EM structure of quinary complex GA3-MtGID1b-MtDELLA1-SLY1-ASK1
Cryo-EM structure of Leu-enkephalin-BMS-986187-bound DOR-Gi2 complex
The receptor local map of asimadoline-BMS-986187-bound KOR-Gi1 complex
Cryo-EM structure of asimadoline-BMS-986187-bound KOR-Gi1 complex
The G PROTEIN map of asimadoline-BMS-986187-bound KOR-Gi1 complex
The receptor local map of Leu-enkephalin-BMS-986187-bound DOR-Gi complex
The Gi protein local map of Leu-enkephalin-BMS-986187-bound DOR-Gi complex
The overall map of Leu-enkephalin-BMS-986187-bound DOR-Gi complex